Pages

Wednesday, October 12, 2016

Oz

L Frank Baum wrote 14 Oz books, and I've read 6 of them.
The first one, despite all its shortcomings is by far the best.

I read them in the order they were written in. When I was on the second one, I suspected that the whole series was going to be a repetition of the original, and two chapters into the third one I was sure.
I'm ashamed to admit I carried on reading the rest because of my pig-headed author centricism.
These 6 are the only ones available as audio books from my libraries, so I'm joyously not reading the other 8. Oh frabjuous day, I said to myself when I was done with the last one.

In the preface to these sequels, the author attributes the story to his fans who "insisted" on more Oz stories. He also claims that he incorporated several of their ideas into these stories.
The Oz series is a perfect example of just why an author should not do that.
The first one was original, and that was the best thing about it. It had a number of inconsistencies however. Like the Tin Woodman who cries when a flower is plucked, but is happy to kill obviously more intelligent life forms like wolves and bees.
Everyone except Dorothy is already in possession of whatever it is they're seeking from the Wizard.
In my opinion, Dorothy was fully aware of this but kept this to herself and decided a bit of company would serve her well. Or they all knew, but wouldn't wish to admit it for fear others would challenge them on that point.
Tin doesn't rust. Iron does. Poppy flowers don't make people sleep.
However since the most general laws of physics have been violated in multiple ways during this, these are just petty and insignificant. (Here, general does not mean more or less true, it means absolutely true, in all generality)

Here's all 6 books that I've read. Even some of the dialogue is repetitive :-(



ABCDEFG
1
In this bookThe Wonderful Wizard of OzThe Marvelous Land of OzOzma of OzDorothy and the Wizard in OzThe Road to OzThe Patchwork Girl of Oz
2
The ProtagonistDorothyTipDorothyDorothy, Zeb, Jim and EurekaDorothy and TotoA munchkin
3
quite against his/her intentions visits the land of OzOzEvthe MangaboosOzOz
4
being taken there bya Cyclonea sawhorsea storman Earthquakea Roadhis Uncle
5
accompanied byToto, a doga sawhorseBillinathe wizard of Ozthe Shaggy ManScraps
6
The protagonist wants to see the Wizard of Ozthe Scarecrow and later, GlindaPrincess LangwidereOzmaOzmaOzma and Dorothy
7
so that they canGo Homeescape MombiGo HomeGo HomeGo HomeUnfreeze his uncle
8
They take along the ScarecrowJack Pumpkinhead9 invisible pigletsPolychromeScraps
9
who doesnt sleep and doesnt get tired or hungry
10
They meet a mechanical man who cannot sleep and who cant be hurt, doesnt get hungry or tiredthe Tin Woodmanthe Tin WoodmanTik TokTik Tokthe Tin Woodman
11
They are accompanied by a creaturethe Cowardly Lionthe Woggle Bugthe hungry tigerJimButton Brightthe Woozy and Bungle
12
who is dealing with a psychological problemfear of everythingbeing highly educated, and considering himself superior to othersalways being hungry and having an inflated consciencebeing oldTabula Rasa mindsetThe Woozy overestimates himself; the Bungle is snobbish
13
They thwartthe Wicked Witch of the WestMombi and General Jingurthe Nome KingGargoyles and invisible bearsthe deadly deserttheir luck
14
Only the protagonist gets what they were seeking
15
the rest of them stay in Oz and they claim to be happy about it



I rate the series a 3.0, and that's only because of the first book. Or it would have been 1.0


Tuesday, October 11, 2016

Dark Matter and Dinosaurs

When I first heard about this, I thought this was rather absurd. How could you possibly tie two popular, yet completely independent ideas? But then when I began reading it, I realized the author meant to relate them. And then, a few chapters down, the idea of a relationship between the two made a lot of sense.

I think Lisa Randall has done well in explaining both concepts to a layman, and to explain how they could be related. I am looking rather forward to hearing about the results of GAIA's experiments.

I rate this a 7.

Sunday, September 11, 2016

Author-centricism

I have read hundreds of books lately. To be precise, I have heard them.
It is most convenient to listen to e-books while I drive to work and back.

I dont have audiobooks from a paid service. I have hooked a couple of library accounts into overdrive.
I can download books in minutes, vary play speed skip ahead if necessary.
However, I do often feel restricted by the supply thats available at NYPL.

For example, I've just blitzed through the Foundation series(for the umpteenth time!) but no library I know has a copy of the e-book for "Robots and Empire".
That book has been particularly difficult to find. It hard copy is not easily available in bookstores either.
I would have also liked to read "Mother Earth" by Asimov, and to hear the extensions to the Foundation universe by other authors. Those are simply not available in ebook form.

I'm also running short of options at this point. I'm an author-centric reader. Meaning once I like an author I will exhaust everything he or she has written.
I've done this with Rex Stout(of Nero Wolfe fame), Isaac Asimov, Philip K Dick, P.G. Wodehouse, Ed McBain, Dick Francis, Lee Child, Franz Kafka.

I have tried to be captivated by other authors, but without much success. I liked a couple of Heinlein stories, I also caught up on some classics I had missed out in my youth(Dostoevsky, Bulgakov).
Unless I find some inspirational new authors, I will have to resort to picking Sci-fi authors out of a hat!

Sunday, July 3, 2016

The three stigmata of palmer eldricht

I re read this book after a long gap. I think I last read it back in 2006 or 2007.
This book is a typical PKD creation. It has the usual premise. A depressed and depressive employee, fatherly employer. Employee likes a girl, does something non-ethical at work, gets fired, sinks into depression and invariably into a world where he loses perception of where he is and what if anything he could have done or could do.
The best part is how masterfully PKD weaves a Web of reality vs unreality. The boundary between a drug induced dream like simulation and a real world is so blurred that the reader won't know what is real anymore.

I rate this a 7. It's not as good as Ubik or Do androids dream of electric sheep? But it's definitely one of PKD'S better works.

Thursday, June 30, 2016

The Double

This is the first time I have read a Dostoevsky novel in its entirety. When I was barely a middle schooler I attempted to read the Idiot and gave up soon enough when I could glean neither amusement nor philosophy. All I remember of the first few pages of the Idiot is that the main character is a prince and that the binding of the book being nearly identical to 1001 questions answered about astronomy caused confusion time and again.

The double was a quick listen. I turned up the speed on overdrive to 2x and was able to finish it rather quickly.

The novel itself was ok, the constant juxtaposition of the protagonist and the doppelganger are done ok-ish. As with any classic there are anachronistic points of view that would be horrible if expressed in this day and age.
However no one does mental illness better than philip k dick and no one does injustice better than Kafka. Still most certainly not a waste of time and I do plan to read more Dostoevsky!

My rating: 6.0

Sunday, April 24, 2016

Ubik

This just has to be one of PKD'S best works. I'm told it was in the time magazine's 100 best novels since the beginning of Time list. I would have agreed with placing Ubik on this list, even if I question the judgement of the selectors given they picked Lolita.

Most of the story is told from the point of Joe Chip's view.
There is an event fairly early in the book, after which the protagonist questions their own existence in a very rational way.
Ubik - what it is, what it does is mysterious all the way to the end. PKD cleverly evokes a theological parallel in the readers mind.

And the ending?  Absolutely PKD!
Just when you are ready to believe everything has been explained well and neatly wrapped up - you find it isnt. The last paragraph leaves everything dangling and forces you to reconsider all that happened, and all the alternatives

Sunday, September 19, 2010

Brave New World

This is a well written work, surprisingly so. The author shows us an elaborate futuristic society that doesn't work. It seems to take a stab at capitalism and  mass production and socislism at the same time.
The scene is set in future Britain where everything including the population is mass produced. People are divided into classes based on their genetic makeup and that governs the rest of their lives. Soma are sleep substitute tablets that keep people efficiently playing their role in turning economic engines of society.

It's not unlike much other criticismof capitalism but this is likely to have been one of the earlier ones.

My rating is a 6, but that's mostly because it's a bit slow at times

Wednesday, September 8, 2010

Do Butlers Burgle Banks?

Yes they can, and in this PGW book, they are capable of much more. Had we had more butlers like Horace Appleby, many a young toddler would aspire to a buttling vocation.
This is one of the first non-drones and non-bertie wooster books that I've read.

Filled with the typical pgw colorful array of characters, one of the main blokes is a bertie wooster like young chappie. There's a butler, horace appleby, who, when he's not burgling banks, is a jeeves like character. There are both a yard man and a country copper.  Claude potter, the scotland yard man I may have read about in other books. The climax in this one is not unlike other pgw works, everyone converges at the scene of the deception a resolution that works for everyone except for the likes of claude potter. Definitely worth reading, this. This gets a 7 on my scale

Wednesday, August 18, 2010

The Man in the High Castle

A PKD book. Its an excellent read, like most PKD books. The pessimism doesnt run as deep here as in the other books. Its an alternate history novel, with Germany and Japan winning WWII, and Italy turning traitor, the breakup of the USA, continent scale genocide in Africa, and German ambitions of expansion in space.
The Japanese life is very nicely depicted, especially the use of the I Ching, which becomes a core part of the culture of native americans living in the Japanese controlled Pacific States of A. Much like the current US influence over Japan.
The ending left many questions, but like most PKD novels and some short stories, the story lies in the meat, rather than in the ending.

Great read, dont miss it.

Sunday, August 15, 2010

What are the chances?

Another popular reading probability book. Why do I keep reading these when I know all this stuff?
Its worth a skip. While examples are well-used etc, you're better off reading Coincidences, Chaos and all that Math Jazz, which itself isnt the best.
The treatment on climate change is quite outdated too, though it was only written in the current decade.

My personal favorite Mathematics books were from Mir publishers. There was this Yakob Perelman or some such person who wrote "Mathematics can be fun". Do read it if you can find it.